Question:
In the following question, a sentence has been given in Active / Passive voice. Out of the four alternatives suggested, select the one which best
expresses the same sentence in Passive / Active voice.
The doctor shall have examined ten patients by 10 O’clock.
In the following question, a sentence has been given in Active / Passive voice. Out of the four alternatives suggested, select the one which best
expresses the same sentence in Passive / Active voice.
The doctor shall have examined ten patients by 10 O’clock.
Options:
- Ten patients will have being examined by 10 O’clock by the doctor.
- Examination of ten patients was being done by the doctor by 10 O’clock.
- Ten patients will have been examined by 10 O’clock by the doctor.
- Examination of ten patients shall have been done by the doctor by 10 O’clock.
- Ten patients will have being examined by 10 O’clock by the doctor.
- Examination of ten patients was being done by the doctor by 10 O’clock.
- Ten patients will have been examined by 10 O’clock by the doctor.
- Examination of ten patients shall have been done by the doctor by 10 O’clock.
Correct Answer: c)
Explanation:
Detailed Explanation:
The correct passive voice sentence is c) Ten patients will have been examined by 10 O’clock by the doctor.
- Tense & Voice Rules:
- The active sentence is in the Future Perfect Tense: Subject + shall/will + have + V3 + Object + Time Expression.
- Active: The doctor (Subject) + shall have examined (Verb) + ten patients (Object) + by 10 O’clock.
- The passive voice rule for Future Perfect Tense is:
Object + will/shall + have been + V3 + by Subject + Time Expression
- Step-by-Step Conversion:
- The object “ten patients” becomes the new subject.
- With a third-person plural subject (ten patients), standard auxiliary is will.
- The verb becomes will have been examined.
- The agent by the doctor and time adverbial by 10 O’clock are appended.
- Why other options are incorrect:
- Option a: Uses “will have being”, which is grammatically incorrect.
- Option b: Changes the tense to past continuous (was being done).
- Option d: Unnecessarily alters the main verb from examined to done.
Hence, Option c is the correct answer.
विस्तृत व्याख्या:
सही Passive Voice वाक्य c) Ten patients will have been examined by 10 O’clock by the doctor. है।
- काल एवं वाच्य के नियम:
- सक्रिय वाक्य (Active Voice) Future Perfect Tense में है: Subject + shall/will + have + V3 + Object।
- Active: The doctor (कर्ता) + shall have examined (क्रिया) + ten patients (कर्म) + by 10 O’clock (समय)।
- Future Perfect Tense का Passive Voice नियम है:
Object + will/shall + have been + V3 + by Subject + Time Adverbial
- चरणबद्ध परिवर्तन:
- कर्म “ten patients” नया कर्ता बनेगा।
- Third-person plural कर्ता (ten patients) के साथ will का प्रयोग होगा।
- क्रिया का रूप will have been examined बनेगा।
- कर्ता by the doctor तथा समय by 10 O’clock जोड़े जाएँगे।
- अन्य विकल्प क्यों गलत हैं:
- विकल्प a में “will have being” व्याकरणिक रूप से अमान्य है।
- विकल्प b में काल बदलकर Past Continuous कर दिया गया है।
- विकल्प d में मुख्य क्रिया examined को बदलकर व्यर्थ ही done कर दिया गया है।
अतः सही उत्तर विकल्प c है।